Wham-a-Wham attacks at first, then pauses for a conversation. Let that dialogue happen if you want the peaceful branch. Sparing him can complete Missing Miners, but it does not award the Cave Troll Trophy from the kill route.
Start in Blandare
Read Contract: Missing Miners and speak to Gjarr in the large house on the village’s eastern side. Go to the miners’ camp north of Blandare. With Witcher Senses, follow the northwest tracks, inspect the crushed body and damaged tree, then continue to the mine. These clues identify a rock troll; a generic search for a griffin cave follows the wrong contract.
Choose after the opening exchange
Inside the mine, defend yourself until the troll stops to talk. Hearing his account lets you decide that the miners ignored his warning and leave him alive after he promises to stop attacking people. That route gives his silver ore and crowns, followed by a smaller reward from Gjarr.
If you instead continue the fight, evade the troll’s slow, signaled attacks and take brief openings. Loot the Cave Troll Trophy after the kill. Exact damage and an optimal Remastered build are not established by this historical walkthrough.
The contract giver closes the task
Return to Gjarr and report the actual outcome. His displeasure with a spared troll is part of that branch, not proof the quest cannot finish. The kill branch requires showing the trophy for the negotiated payment. A missing trophy after a documented kill is a different symptom; preserve the save and use the missing-trophy diagnosis without assuming it guarantees repair of this contract.
Sources and limits
Sources checked October 23, 2026. These are attributed instructions, not our own playtest. Historical quest routes do not establish that every Remastered build or modded save is free of scripting problems. Keep a separate save before a consequential choice.