Follow the moonshine trail from Rostan Muggs to Gerd at the Seven Cats Inn, recover the property document, then return it to Muggs.
Follow the quest checkpoints
- Find Rostan Muggs by the bridge outside Novigrad’s Southern Gate, toward Farcorners. He claims someone stole his papers after a drinking encounter.
- Inspect the broken bottle with Witcher Senses. Follow the alcohol scent across the bridge and along the road toward the Seven Cats Inn; simply searching Novigrad houses misses the next NPC.
- Speak to Gerd outside the inn. His account is different: he won the document at Gwent. You can recover it through a Gwent match, a fistfight or the dialogue Axii option actually available to your character. Offering to buy it is not the documented solution.
- Return to Muggs with the document. His explanation resolves the disagreement and the journal should complete the quest. The historical walkthrough lists a small crown reward; do not expect a large city-level payout.
If the next step is missing
The legacy suggested level is 2: it describes this errand’s difficulty, not the level of every Novigrad quest. A November 2 player discussion asks exactly why a city quest can have such a low recommendation. If the trail ends without a conversation, check the outside seating at the Seven Cats Inn and the currently tracked objective before assuming a broken save. Compare the two accounts before choosing a fight.
Sources and limits
- GameBanshee: document recovery route
- Gamer Walkthroughs: Muggs and Gerd
- November 2 player question about the suggested level
Checked November 2, 2026. These attributed historical walkthroughs establish the route, not a new Remastered playtest. Menu wording, rewards and scripting can differ by version or mods. Keep a separate save before an irreversible choice.