Quests & Gwent

Witcher 3 A Greedy God: find the Allgod and compare the offerings choice

Use the Eye of Nehaleni to expose the cellar and decide whether the sylvan should accept smaller offerings.

Follow the wine scent and use the Eye of Nehaleni on the illusionary rocks to reach the Allgod. You can persuade the sylvan to accept smaller offerings during the war instead of killing him or leaving his demands unchanged.

Bring the illusion tool

After receiving the Eye in Wandering in the Dark, speak to Dagmar and Preben at Wastrel Manor. Hear the altar’s demands. Inspect the spilled wine with Witcher Senses and follow its scent to the rocks concealing the cellar. Remove the illusion and descend. Hitting ordinary rocks elsewhere or repeatedly using Aard does not replace the Eye interaction.

What each response changes

  • Accept the demands: the peasants continue providing the better offerings the sylvan wants.
  • Negotiate: convince him to accept what the peasants can afford until the war ends. This is the documented nonviolent compromise.
  • Kill him: defeat the sylvan and report the outcome; the peasants are unhappy about losing their supposed god.

There is no necessary boss fight just because you uncovered the deception. Preserve a cellar-entry save if you want to compare the moral outcomes.

Separate the quest from later speculation

Return to the peasants and finish the conversation. Historical reports disagree about the later outcome of telling them to enter the cellar; this page does not promise their safety, a repeatable reward or one universal scene afterward. If you want to avoid that uncertain extra branch, finish the chosen offering outcome without directing them below.

Sources and limits

Sources checked October 23, 2026. These are attributed instructions, not our own playtest. Historical quest routes do not establish that every Remastered build or modded save is free of scripting problems. Keep a separate save before a consequential choice.