Build ten charges, then kill an enemy while fully charged to earn permanent damage while the sword has unused growth allowance. Charges are temporary; the tooltip’s earned increase and maximum are permanent-growth counters. At character level 100 you can still fill unused allowance, but another character level will not open more room in an unmodified level 100 game.
Blood and Wine quest-reward Aerondight. Vanilla mechanics described by attributed sources; mods can change charges, growth and level caps. This is not a current best-sword ranking.
Read the two systems separately
| Value | What changes it | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|
| Combat charges, up to 10 | Successful attacks; charges decay or are lost when damaged. Full charge gives guaranteed critical hits. | A disappearing combat stack is not necessarily lost permanent progress. |
| Earned permanent increase | A full-charge killing blow, while below the allowance | Ordinary hits or an early kill do not complete this requirement. |
| Maximum permanent increase | The character-level allowance | It is not the weapon’s entire damage range or automatically a percentage. |
Use a repeatable check
- Save, equip the actual quest-reward silver sword, and note its earned increase and maximum.
- Choose a manageable enemy that survives long enough to build charges. Protect the stack; Quen can help avoid taking damage.
- Reach ten charges before the killing blow.
- Read the tooltip again after the kill. In the cited vanilla explanation, a qualifying kill adds 2 permanent damage and a new character level adds 10 to the allowance.
- Stop farming once earned increase equals maximum. More ordinary combat cannot fill room that does not exist.
These numbers describe the cited unmodified mechanic. Check your installed item text before applying them to a modded sword. The current True Aerondight mod author explicitly lists different values; installing that mod is not a prerequisite for normal growth.
A larger bonus cap does not choose the better sword
Keep both swords while comparing them. Note the actual displayed damage range, already-earned increase, remaining room and other effects on each. Compare the same equipment and temporary-buff state. Do not add the earned bonus a second time to a damage value that already includes it.
An older sword may show a much larger growth number because it was acquired earlier. An NG+ copy may start from a higher base. Neither observation alone decides the fully developed result. At level 100, compare current damage and remaining allowance; do not wait for an impossible next vanilla level. A current player’s 500-versus-80 question prompted this distinction, but their screenshots were not independently measured here.
Check the failure before changing the save
- Earned value equals maximum: the growth allowance is filled.
- Enemy dies too soon: confirm ten charges existed before the kill.
- Charges disappear after a hit: compare the permanent tooltip, not just the combat display.
- Values differ from this guide: record the sword identity and mods before assuming save corruption.
Completion: the earned value moves after a qualifying kill, or you can identify that the current allowance is already full. Still need the sword? Follow the five-virtues acquisition route. For enchantment sockets, use the Runewright unlock and budget.
Sources and limits
- RelicTrek: Aerondight — Charge/growth separation and level-based limit.
- GamesStarter: growth and allowance — Attributed +2/+10 explanation, not our benchmark.
- True Aerondight mod author — Explicitly distinguishes its changed rules from vanilla.
- October 17 player question — Original and visible replies read; numerical screenshots not verified.
Sources checked October 17, 2026. Attributed instructions, not our own game test. Match your platform, installed version and mods; historical routes are not a universal 5.x compatibility guarantee.
